"

II. FROM OPTICAL TO VISUAL EFFECTS

13. THE MEASUREMENT PROBLEM

In the 1600s, the invention of the telescope, microscope, thermometer, and clock provided unprecedented means of measuring things and effects. Measurement was a key factor in the advancement of knowledge in physics, chemistry, and biology in the 1700s. That led to the Industrial Revolution in the 1800s, which provided the technology for even better measurements.

Today, technology provides radiometers that can measure the density of photons as focused on the retina in terms of energy (radiance) – see Appendix D – Measuring Light. Microvolt meters can measure their absorption by the -70 to -40 mV changes as ion gates open and close in photoreceptors. Micropipettes can sample the ions producing these voltages. Microelectrodes can count the nerve impulses leaving retinal ganglion cells. Computerized amplifiers can measure the size of the response by neurons in the visual cortex.

However, the relationship between such physical effects and the conscious sensation of “brightness” is where matters get complicated. In the 1700s, a different sort of “technology” was needed for an understanding of the mind to progress beyond philosophy. By a most unlikely route, this breakthrough began with a need to measure the efficiency of lamps to enable pocketing the savings in whale oil cost:

Benjamin Thompson was a New Hampshire Loyalist, spy, and British soldier during the American Revolution. After the war, he abandoned his wife and daughter to seek favor at court in England and Europe. In 1784, he garnered a lucrative appointment in Bavaria as Minister of Supplies. Thereupon, he sought to build lamps for his workhouses that produced light more efficiently. However, he found that brightness judgments were not consistent enough to determine which lamp produced the most light. While lacking any technology that could measure the amount of light, he knew about the Inverse Square Law of Radiation (Ch 4), that Issac Newton had published some 60 years earlier. It could be used to vary the brightness that a lamp produces on a white surface. It occurred to him to vary the distance of two lamps from such a screen until their brightness matched. The ratio of their distances then indicated their relative light output. [1]


Steps Towards Measuring What We See

Thompson used visual brightness to measure physical energy indirectly. Over 60 years later, in 1851, Gustav Fechner reversed what Thompson did. Namely, Fechner measured brightness indirectly in terms of a physical measurement of light energy. He identified three perceptual effects that could be measured physically:

1. Measuring a physical condition, such as light intensity, when its sensory effect disappears –the effect’s threshold.

2. Measuring how much of a physical change was necessary for an observer to notice a change -the effect’s difference-threshold.

3. Measuring the physical conditions needed to make one sensation match another -their relative strength.

Fechner developed three ways to measure these effects:

1. The Method of Limits gradually changes the strength of a stimulus or the difference between two stimuli and has the participant report when the stimulus or a difference is seen. The change can either be continuous or stepwise. Either the experimenter, or a computer, or the participant may do the changing. In the latter case, it is also called the Method of Adjustment.

2. The Method of Constant Stimuli presents specific stimuli at various levels of strength or difference in random order and has the participant to report if the stimuli were seen, differed, or matched. The measurement is based on how often each level is seen. The level that is seen half the time defines the threshold.

3. The Method of Matching is used in two distinct ways.

   3.1 Measuring Difference-Thresholds The procedure is similar to the Method of Limits except it has the participant decide when two copies of a stimulus match as one of them is varied in strength. The variability of the repeated matches indicates the difference-threshold.

   3.2 Cross-Modality Matching can be used to measure the strength of various levels of complex stimuli that are difficult to adjust. [2] It can also be used to compare different stimuli based on some common attribute that can be cognitively inferred.

4. Reaction Time – While not invented by Fechner, this method uses the same strategy of measuring subjective sensory and cognitive effects in terms of a physical effect. This method originated with Helmholtz’ use of human reaction time to measure the speed of nerve conduction. (The longer delay in responding to mild shocks to a fingertip than to the shoulder was attributed to its greater distance from the brain.) In 1868, Francis Donders reasoned that since nerve conduction took time, the processing of different sensations and different cognitive tasks likely involved different neural pathway lengths. Therefore, they would require different amounts of time. This led to measuring their operation in terms of reaction time.

Appendix E – Psychophysical Methods explains how these methods work. They were the basis for a new science that used experiments to study perception and cognition – Psychology. Over the next 40 years, these methods improved technology (together with relative peace of the Victorian Era) enabled ever more precise measurements of vision, hearing, and touch. These revealed systematic properties in sensory effects ranging from brightness to weight perception. The results beckoned explanation based on the growing knowledge of neuroanatomy and neurophysiology during this period. By 1894, a leading psychologist, G.E. Müller, confidently proclaimed, “The ground of every state of consciousness is a material process -”. [3]

A perception of “brightness” also provided the first direct evidence of Müller’s proclamation that cognition was determined physiologically. Like many “breakthroughs”, it was unexpected. In 1934, S. Howard Bartley was studying how the retina was mapped into the brain by flashing a light into a rabbit’s eye and recording the electrical responses from its visual cortex. One day, he changed the flashing frequency while recording and noticed that the cortical responses suddenly grew huge at 12 Hz. Then they declined as he went to higher or lower frequencies. The increased response amplitude was similar to the response evoked by brighter flashes, though the flash brightness had not changed. (That possibility was carefully checked.) Then he looked at the light himself and saw that it did appear brighter at 12 Hz! This led Bartley to propose a theory that temporal patterns of neural activity, as well as neuroanatomy, determine visual qualities. [4]


  1. Thompson B (1794) An account of a method of measuring the comparative intensities of the light emitted by luminous bodies. Proceedings of the Royal Society, IX, 67-106. According to Brown SC (1979, Benjamin Thompson, Count Rumford. Cambridge: MIT Press) Thompson did not invent this light measuring method. Though not acknowledged, he likely knew about the method from Pierre Bouguer’s 1729 treatise on its use to measure the decrease in light by transmission through air according to Middleton WEK (1971) The beginnings of photometry. Applied Optics, 12, 2592-2594). Yet, by using a standard lamp, he essentially invented the photometer.Based on his subsequent research to develop more efficient stoves, Thompson proposed the theory of heat that led to thermodynamics. He co-founded the Royal Institute in London, where his assistant, Michael Faraday discovered the interaction of electricity and magnetism. Subsequently, Faraday’s student, James Clerk Maxwell developed the wave equations that unified radiation, electricity, and magnetism in 1865. These equations are the foundation of the technology that has revolutionized our lives and understanding of the universe. On the other hand, Thompson’s insight into measuring brightness led the way to measure consciousness. ↵
  2. p. 56 Francis Galton felt that our ability to count represented quantitative understanding of quantity and strength in terms of numbers. In 1883 he had participants match the vividness of images to numbers from 1 to 10. From this developed the use of rating scales to measure just about anything such as pain, fatigue, happiness, quality of life, beauty, and social opinions using the ubiquitous questionnaire. ↵
  3. Boring, EG (1957) A History of Experimental Psychology - 2nd Ed., New York, Appleton-Century-Crofts, p. 665. Improved methods and apparatus would not have led to this rapid progress without another development. Psychophysical measurements are much more variable than measurements in physics and biology. Sensory thresholds, for example, can differ markedly when repeated. Fortunately, by the mid-1800s, the growth of commercial and government records had led to statistics progressing from probabilities in gambling to working with large sets of economic and social data. Statistics finally enabled psychologists to reach consistent conclusions despite the variability of their measurements. ↵
  4. Bartley SH (1934) Relation of intensity and duration of brief retinal stimulation by light to the electric response of the optic cortex of the rabbit, American J. Physiology, 108. 397-408. After World War 2, Bartley and his students conducted numerous experiments measuring how temporal patterns of light altered the perception of brightness, color, and shape: Bartley SH (1964) Some sensory end results and the neural activity of the optic pathway, American J. Optometry, Monograph 328. His theory led to the discovery that various pulse durations change the color of monochromatic light differently from how color changes with brightness: Nilsson TH (1972) Effects of pulse duration and pulse rate on hue of monochromatic stimuli, Vision Research,12, 1907-1921. For a recent example of such research, see Zhou H, et al, (2020) Spatial temporal dynamics of brightness coding in human visual cortex revealed by the temporal context effect. NeuroImage, 205, 116277. ↵

License

Icon for the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License

The Picture in Your Head Copyright © by Thomy Nilsson is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, except where otherwise noted.

Share This Book