"

IV. STEPS TOWARDS CONSCIOUSNESS

33. THEORIES AND CONCLUSION

Four overlapping neurophysiological approaches explaining the picture-in-our-head are evident in the research literature:

1. Intra-Cellular Mechanisms

The complexity of neurons’ internal structure and function has led to theories that consciousness arises within neurons. [1] This would make conscious processing comparable to the processes that induce cellular identity to shape our body. While morphogenesis is not fully understood, there seems to be no need to invoke non-biological explanations. Since genetics organizes the specific sensory processes, that genetics could also produce their subjective effects is conceivable and would be efficient.

2. Ionic Fields

Much of the visual system’s processing involves analyzing the retinal image into spatial frequencies (Fourier Analysis). While this is the most efficient known means of transmitting and storing images, It is not clear how the results of this analysis are related to the picture-in-your-head. Karl Pribram proposes that an image arises by synthesizing the spatial frequency information. [2] Yet where and how that synthesis occurs is complexly related to ionic local fields imposed on the watery layer surrounding the dendrites of cortical neurons as they respond to neurotransmitter inputs.

3. Neural Node Microconsciousness

Neural correlates of specific conscious effects can be localized to a few millimeters of cortex using MRI recorded responses to visual stimuli. Zeki (2001) proposes that these nodes, which contain some 100,000 neurons and hundreds of millions synapses, themselves generate a local consciousness. [3]  That these micro-conscious effects occur in parallel all over the brain suffices to create a global consciousness without a connective hierarchy.

4. Electromagnetic Fields

Most human experiments on consciousness use non-invasive EEG and fMRI measurements to see what is happening in the brain. They seek neural correlates of consciousness (NCC) in response to sensory stimuli, cognitive performance, and specific behaviors. By controlling the measurement situation and carefully varying the task strengths, the premise is that such correlations indicate causal connections between the neural activity and what is seen. Yet the question remains whether the measured or indicated electromagnetic fields produce a conscious image. [4]

5. Computational Emergence

Integrated Information Theory (IIT)

This theory can trace its origins to Harry Jerison’s (1976) proposal that consciousness was a mammalian adaptation to cope with information overflow by integrating it all into what we experience as consciousness.[5] Subsequently, many scientists, including associates of two Noble Prize winners, Gerald Edelman and Francis Crick, have proposed that consciousness “emerges” with complex information processing in the brain. [6] IIT suggests that sensory images occur in the sensory processing areas of the brain. How the consciousness occurs is explained by analogy to how life emerges from the complex organization of biological molecules.

Global Workspace Theory (GWT),

Championed by Bernard Baars and Stanislas Dehaene, is widely recognized by both scientists and philosophers. [7] Implicitly it relies on computational emergence. However, it focuses on how various cognitive and attentive functions interact with sensory processes to produce consciousness. GWT suggests that consciousness occurs in the pre-frontal cortex. It is not clear whether this is necessary for sensory awareness.

Artificial Consciousness:

If integrating information can produce consciousness, it may not matter whether those mathematical operations are performed by neural networks or some other means. This has led to speculation that computers running artificial intelligence programs experience consciousness. [8]

The computational approach to consciousness arose from early views of neurons as on-off (digital) devices, based on how they produce impulses. On-off switches configured as relays can be configured to perform basic logic operations such as AND, OR, and NAND. Assembled into mechanical systems, such logic devices can perform mathematical and complex automated operations. Later, vacuum tubes, and then transistors replaced relays. The central processors in 2025 home computers have more transistor switches than the human brain has neurons. In principle these transistors could be replicated with billions of relays to run artificial intelligence programs. If just doing such calculations sufficed, a vast building full of relays could be conscious.

Nerve impulses are only a means of transmitting information. All change occurs at the synapses between neurons. Graded interactions between multiple neurotransmitters, modulators, and receptors at the synaptic membranes enable effects whose complexity remains to be fully understood. [9] Mere on-off digital operations seem unlikely to achieve consciousness – no matter how many are used. [10]

For more extensive reviews of neurophysiological theories, see Gassab L, Pusuluk O, Cattaneo M & Mustecaplioglu OE (2025) Quantum Models of consciousness from a quantum information science perspective. arXiv: 2501.03241v2 [q-bio.NC] 26 Feb 2025}; Seth AK & Bayne T (2022) Theories of consciousness. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 23, 439-452;

Recent books with a neuroscience perspective on consciousness intended for a general readership: Antonio Damasio’s (2012) Self Comes to Mind {Random House, New York} adds a disciplined perspective on how feelings and emotions are based on neural and hormonal signals that inform the brain about homeostatic needs such as hunger and pain. George Musser’s (2023) Putting Ourselves in the Equation: Why Physicists Are Studying Human Consciousness and AI to Unravel the Mysteries of the Universe {Farrar, Straus & Giroux, New York} provides a physical sciences approach, while John Parrington’s (2024) Consciousness: How our Minds Turn Matter into Meaning {Icon Books, London} provides a bio-chemical perspective. Richard Underwood (2025) summarizes a broad range of theories in A Brief History of Consciousness {DOI: 10.6084/m9.figshare.28540919}.


CONCLUSION

At the 1998 annual Association for the Scientific Study of Consciousness meeting, Christof Koch bet David Chalmers that in 25 years the Hard Problem would be solved. At the 2023 meeting, Koch acknowledged losing that bet. Nevertheless, Koch was willing to bet again that it would be solved in another 25 years.

The answer must originate with the genetic mechanisms that map out our bodies – skin, bones, organs, and nerves.[11] From structure arises function: homeostasis, sensory processing, motor control, learning ability, and cognition. We understand these to be biological processes, though much remains to be learned about cognition and memory.

Yet consciousness seems to be different. Neither the electromagnetic fields generated by ionic impulses, nor those impulses surging through neural networks, nor the chemical soup of released neurotransmitters, nor the myriad protein reactions within thousands of neurons would seem to be the “picture-in-our-head”. While it must result from neurophysiology, the image itself is not material. It changes too fast and has too many potential qualities at any location.

Revonsuo (2021) acknowledges that if we do not find a neural basis of consciousness in the brain, ”the science of consciousness may be forced to reconsider its metaphysical basis.” [12] However, that would entail a revolution in science. Perhaps that is not so bad. Consider how electricity was discovered:

In 1780 Luigi Galvani curiously poked into a frog to see what made its legs kick. What he discovered was something entirely new. It changed the world. Where else at that time would one find something so complicated and still as available for study with the means then available?

Where today is the equivalent of that frog? [13]

Thank you for reading,

Thomy Nilsson


  1. Stuart Hameroff (2022) Proposes that post-synaptic responses create quantal resonance patterns inside the neurons’ microtubules. This briefly produces a local distinctness that creates an image fragment. {Consciousness, cognition and the neuronal cytoskeleton - A new paradigm needed in neuroscience. Frontiers in Molecular Neuroscience, 15, 869935 {doi:10.3389/fnmol.2022.869935}. Another approach is proposed by Aru J, Bahmann T, Suzuki M & Larkum ME (2020): Membrane vibrations in the dendrites of pyramidal neurons generate unique surface charge patterns {Primer on the Dendritic Integration Theory of Consciousness. IOPenAIRE EXPLORE {doi: 10.31234/ osf.io/vkdt2}. Adams B & Petruccione F (2019) review several of these theories {adXiv:1910.08423v1 [q-bio.NC] 17 Oct 2019}. ↵
  2. Jibu M, Pribram KH & Yasue K (1996) From conscious experience to memory storage and retrieval: The role of quantum brain dynamics and boson condensation or evanescent photons. International Journal of Modern Physics, B, 10, 1735-1754. Alemdar E, Poznanski RR, Cacha LA, Leisman G & Brandas EJ (2023) New insights into holonomic brain theory: implications for active consciousness. Journal of Multiscale Neuroscience, 2, 159-168. ↵
  3. Zeki S (2001) Localization and globalization in conscious vision. Annual Review of Neuroscience, 24, 24-57. ↵
  4. Bond E (2023) The contributions of coherence field theory to a model of consciousness: electric currents, EM fields, and EM radiation in the brain. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 16,1020105; {doi:10.3389/fhum2022.1020105}. This editorial leads to a series of open access papers: Hunt T, et al. (2024) Editorial: Electromagnetic field theories of consciousness: opportunities and obstacles. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 3, 1-4 {doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2023.1342634}. ↵
  5. Based on Jerison HJ (1991) Brain Size and the Evolution of Mind. American Museum of Natural History, New York: As the story goes, mammals developed warm bodies (homeothermic) to compete against cold-bodied reptiles when the Earth’s temperature declined about 250 million years ago. However, shortly thereafter, the climate warmed again. This left mammals with unnecessarily complex bodies that were slower to adapt than reptiles. As dinosaurs evolved, mammals continued to lose in competing for territory. Finally, mammals survived by dwelling in burrows. Underground, vision was useless for finding food and mates. Therefore, they expanded information processing for smell, sound, touch, and memory by adding networks in the neocortex. (See the brain diagram in Appendix A.) ↵
  6. Crick F& Koch C (1990) Towards a neurobiological theory of consciousness. Seminars in the Neurosciences, 2, 273-304. Edelman GM & Tononi G (2000) A Universe of Consciousness, Basic Books, N.Y. For further discussion about emergence, see: Guevara R, Mateos DM & Velazquez JLP (2020) Consciousness as an emergent phenomenon: A tale of different levels of description. Entropy, 22, 921 {doi:10.3390/e22090921}, and Miller EK, Brincat SL & Roy JE (2024) Cognition as an emergent property. Current Opinion in the Behavioral Sciences, 57, 101388 {doi.org/10.1016/j.cobehav.2024.101388}. ↵
  7. Baars, BJ (2021) On Consciousness: Science and Subjectivity: Updated Works on Global Workspace Theory. Nautilus Press, New York, ISBN 978-1-7329048-8-7 (ebook). Dehaene S & Naccache L (2001) Towards a cognitive neuroscience of consciousness: basic evidence and a workspace framework. Cognition, 79, 1-37. ↵
  8. Butlin P, et al. (2023) Consciousness in artificial intelligence: Insights from the science of consciousness. ArXiv:2308.008708v3 {Farisco M, Evers K & Changeux J-P (2024) Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the human brain. Neural Networks, 180, 106714 {doi.org/10.1016/jneunet.2024.106714}. ↵
  9. Oostrum M van & Schumann EM (2025) Understanding the molecular diversity of synapses. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 26, 65-81. ↵
  10. Findlay G, Marshall W, Albantakis L, David I, Mayner WGP, Koch C, & Tononi G (2024) Dissociating artificial intelligence from artificial consciousness. ArXiv:2412.04571v1. Jones MW (2019) Growing evidence that perceptual qualia are neuroelectrical not computational. Journal of Consciousness Studies, 16, 89-116. ↵
  11. Fitch T (2023) Cellular computation and cognition. Frontiers in Computational Neuroscience, 17,: 1107876 {doi: 10.3389/fncom.2023.1107876} ↵
  12. Fitch T (2023) Cellular computation and cognition. Frontiers in Computational Neuroscience, 17,: 1107876 {doi: 10.3389/fncom.2023.1107876 ↵
  13. Hulick K (2025) Making AI think more like your brain. Science News, 207, 8, 40-47. ↵

License

Icon for the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License

The Picture in Your Head Copyright © by Thomy Nilsson is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, except where otherwise noted.

Share This Book